Wendong's profileWD Sailing LogPhotosBlogListsMore ![]() | Help |
|
9/7/2009 Cambridge Town
Associated with names such as Francis Bacon, Sir Issac Newton, James Maxwell, Charles Darwin, Watson and Crick, in Cambridge one has every reason to be serious, yet Cambridge students decidedly do not take themselves too seriously. The photo is the front page of Cambridge student newspaper May 2009 issue, which I took from the tourist center in Cambridge University. The year 2009 happens to be the 800th anniversary of this ancient institute, and the front page depicts this 800th graduating class in the most disarrayed form. The student newspaper is merely one illustration of the light-hearted spirit of Cambridge. Another amusing story I learned is about the champion of the Cambridge pub crawl. The latest winner drank 14 pints in 17 minutes, and was presented a green scarf after his feat, presumably to match the color of his face. The university administration certainly does not like its students spending all their time entertaining themselves. And that's why the Cambridge railway station is built so far away from the university town. The campus police, as I was told, had the authority to arrest any student in possession of a ticket to London on the platform when the station was first built. Another anecdote has to do with the first woman college Girton College. When it was first opened in 1870s, it was located 30 miles from Cambridge, with the intention to keep its female students from "male distractions". The name Cambridge alone inspires awes and admiration, yet the campus is full of refreshing youthful spirits, sometimes defiant and mischievous. Despite its age, Cambridge is still a quintessential example of vibrant university town. Its success may just depend on this very defiant and mischievous spirit of youth, which is best captured by Rudyard Kipling in "Taking everything you like seriously, except yourselves. " 8/29/2009 New York City - ManhattanStarted as a trading post for the Dutch West India Company in 1624, New York City (Manhattan more precisely since the rest four boroughs didn’t join officially until 1898) gradually became the major port of trade between North America and Europe during the 17th and 18th centuries. And as the business in the then “new” continent flourishes and with more and more immigrants coming in, NYC grew bigger and bigger in much the same ways as the new land did. The inevitable clashes between the old and the new worlds began in August 1776. They won, of course, and George Washington delivered his first inauguration address in 1789 in this city. The layout of Manhattan streets indicates the city is very well planned: the neatly divided streets in middle and uptown, and the naming of the streets — 1st to 7th ave from east to west, and 1st to around 160th streets from south to north. This would be boring for many, but is very convenient for visitors to locate themselves in the overcrowded little island. Some of the traditional must-sees in Manhattan include the Statue of Liberty, the Metropolitan Museum of Arts (the Met), Guggenheim Museum, Museum of Modern Arts (MoMA), Central Park, Financial district and Times Square. Central Park is by far my favorite in the city. Its size is relatively large considering the limited real estate in such a narrow island, and the crowd doing morning exercising is most impressive to me. They jog, bike, doing stretch and yoga and all other kinds of exercises. In central park, I feel the real vitality of the city, and lively, natural, warm and human aspects of the land, whereas the busy bees in business attire on wall street offers a tense urban passion. The Met is huge, which could easily take up a whole week, or even a life time, as one of the museum curators told us: he had been in the Met for 32 years and yet has not seen it all. Millions of other smaller museums offer collections that will satisfy your special interest. Manhattan is of course not just about museums, parks and streets. A whopping 46% of the population speak another language at home. Here on subway, you can hear most major languages around the world. Chinatown, little Italy, and other ethnic centers are scattered around the downtown areas. Walking around the streets in Manhattan is already a scene by itself, but if you need a higher dose of entertainment, theaters are abound. Mamma Mia!, Lion King, Chicago are some of the current shows, costly though. Some practicalities. Cost is the major concern for budget travelers. The hostel I lived in costs $35 per night, and plus the food around $15 per day, so $50 per day is for barely survival. The museum admission fee is around $10 each, and if you want to really learn something, an audio set is a must, which would add another $5. The theater ticket is totally another story: they could easily go up to around $100 if you are looking for a decent seating or a popular show. Eating at a common restaurant would cost you around $15 for lunch and $25 for dinner, and tax (8%) and tipping (10-20%) will add 15-25% more of whatever you pay. Though the best way to explore the city is on foot, at least in theory, the subway/bus is a cheap way to get around. You can get the Metrocard in any subway station by cash or credit cards. They offer prepaid card (2.25 per ride), one day pass($8.25), and seven day week pass($27.25). You may benefit from studying (yes studying) the subway system fully before entering the underground because it is the most complicated subway system I have ever seen. They use colors, letters, numbers, and geometry in order to distinguish trains. Two or three trains may share the same line for quite a distance. For example, 4,5,6 trains share the same line on most part of the east Manhattan, and only diverge when they are near the boundaries of Manhattan. The difference between “local” and “express” are usually distinguished by the geometry around the number. Take 7 for example, 7 in diamond is the express train, meaning it won’t stop in some stations, and 7 in circle is the local train, meaning it will stop at all the stations. So you may guess already that the symbol for the stations are different as well, plus different types of connections, shuttle buses, and stations that you cannot get to the opposite direction without getting out of the station. Anyway, good luck reading the map. 8/28/2009 NYC day 3 & 4![]() So this is where the money is shuffled and disappeared.
Time square is not so impressive during the day.
This is one of only a handful of works that I know of before my visit to the Museum of Modern Arts, the so-called MoMA.
Frankly, this is my response to most of the works displayed in MoMA: "mmm, what the heck does the artist want to tell?" The painting is Vir Heroicus Sublimis (Man, Heroic and sublime) by Barnett Newman.
And occasionally, oof... ( the painting is by Edward Ruscha)
Waste Not, by Dong Song. Tons of used old stuff for arts and reflection.
The Lady.
Manhattan from a distance. It would be too depressing to live in those buildings where the only thing you can see through your windows is other windows. 8/26/2009 NYC day 1 & 2
I am very very impressed by the large size of crowd doing morning exercises in central park. They are the vitality of a city. Watching them jogging makes me want to join them, except that I have the camera.
I have always hated museum, until I went to Met. Now I know that I haven't been to good ones. Completely overwhelmed, I spent almost 6 hours in it, but still couldn't see it all.
Struggle of the Two Natures in Man, by George Grey Barnard. The theme is repeated everywhere in western arts: the light and dark, the civil and savage in every individual. I begins to think it is just nature of blood.
The artist, Georgia O'Keeffe, said a good painting requires the time
of a good friend. After the work of arts is finished, the work of heart
begins. This black Iris shows the budding, blooming, fading and dying
of a flower. According to the orientation guy, the pic gives all the necessary parts for you to reconstruct
whatever you imagine. For me, it is more about satisfying the curiosity
than appreciating the arts. I believe it is not until one picks up the brush and starts his own trials on the canvas, he won't know exactly how to appreciate those works. The same is true for all kinds of sports and music. You won't know what is good soccer until you played it by yourself, and you won't know what is good music until you tries to lay down some of the notes yourself.
I am not so impressed by the American Museum of Natural History. Skeleton everywhere. The real highlight of this trip is the show of Journey of the Stars in the planetarium, but no photograph is allowed inside.
This is what we will all become, after all "we all gonna to die, it's just a matter of time". In this sense, we all have the same beginning and the same ending; it is what we do in between that distinguishes every individual.
In the hall of American Museum of Nature History, there are four
huge engravings of quotes by Theodore Roosevelt on Youth, Nature,
Manhood, and State. One reads: "Character in the long run is the
decisive factor in the life of an individual and of nations alike." It's not power, intelligence, or fortune, but character. 8/15/2009 WD sailing log
People always like to see themselves as being at the center of the world and proudly enjoy doing so. A map sold in China will put China at the center, one sold in Europe will put Europe at the center, one sold in Australia, as I was told, will put the south hemisphere on the top and Australia at the center. The fact is that the earth is, thank heaven, round. You can see it in whatever ways you like and whatever ways that satisfy the collective pride of a people, a pride that is sometimes justified and necessary. This summer trip starts from the unabashedly dubbed capital of the new world, NYC, to the de facto capital of the old world, London, with an excursion to Edinburgh to satisfy my own longtime curiosity of Scotland bagpipe and kilt. Five years ago, Bob Xu showed me a book called With Three Thousand USD, I traveled around the world. It was a fascinating book to read at that time, for it not only gave an account of a world totally exotic to me, but also showed the possibility of seeing the world without first being ridiculously rich. As my younger cousin recited the lesson Nothing to Sell and Nothing to Buy in New Concept English to me over Skype several weeks ago, I was quite delightful to see the connection between me and a tramp, or in fact, any backpacker and a tramp. A part of the lesson reads "His few material possession make it possible for him to move from place to place with ease. By having to sleep in the open, he gets far closer to the world of nature than most of us ever do. He may hunt, beg, or steal occasionally to keep himself alive; he may even in times of real need, do a little work; but he will never sacrifice his freedom." Backpacking is not about a bag, a ticket, a hostel and a destination, that’s what backpacking needs, not what it is. What backpacking really is is wherever you want to go, you go. 6/28/2009 Green dam![]() When I was setting up my first website justluck.cn with 512j.com back in 2005, I remember that I have to get a license from the Ministry of Information Industry (now the Ministry of Industry and Information), even though it is just for personal use. According the agreement, the license has to be placed in a place easy to be seen. I don't feel much trouble at that time then, except that the Ministry's website is poorly designed that it is not very easy to navigate around. For the past a few days, I have been keeping track of the demonstration in Iran. And the Iranian postdoc in my lab told me yesterday during lunch time that he couldn't even contact his parents because all means of communication to the outside world are shut. I asked why so. He said that the government installed a software in every cell phone which was initally for tracking child pornograph, but is now used for tracking any communication among demonstrators. As soon as they locate one demonstrator's home, they will go to his/her place, tortue him/her and then force him/her to log into the computer and find all his frineds on social networking website such as facebook and twitter (which are being used heavily for demonstrators to get organized) to locate more protesters. He was apparently emotionally charged when he told me about it. And what he said deeply troubles me. Blocking pornography seems just a smoke screen for keeping the mass from getting the information. Such measures bears the appearance of righteousness and indeed create a delightful ignorance. But it may be dangerous if used in the wrong hands, and even if correctly used, it creates an over-protection that might eventually indulge the next generation. Also troublesome is its apparent hypocrisy: You say what you want to do is blocking pornography, but actually what you want to achieve is something else. This obvious manipulation insult the intelligence of those who have sound judgment. 防民之口,甚于防川。 4/19/2009 还是有明白人的
--《南方周末》原文:http://www.infzm.com/content/27048 --《中国青年报》原文:http://zqb.cyol.com/content/2009-04/08/content_2613961.htm which reminds me of the cartoon:
And this comment about the book "Unhappy China":
1/24/2009 so, 2008 is goneI was reading Toronto Star at breakfast this morning, and was disappointed to learn The Dark Knight was not nominated for Oscar best picture. I was also amused by the movie critic Peter Howell, who bemoaned that Oscar would "slide deeper into irrelevancy".
In The Dark Knight, the Batman is more of a human, and naturally has personal struggles. The most dramatic of the movie is that the Batman becomes a villain's sidekick, and that villain is, of course, the joker. The irony is explained by the butler Alfred in a dialogue with Bruce.
Also revealed is the relevance of this movie in this post-heroic time. In the movie, the batman hammered the mob to desperation, so the mob reluctantly sought help from joker, who promised to kill the batman. The joker, a self-proclaimed "agent of chaoz", actually don't care about the mob's money. He mocked the mob and police alike, and through a series of murder and conspiracy, turned the city upside-down, inducing panic among people and the city. You might already see the real life analogy here. The only superpower in the world did what it think is "right" to fight enemy. Its enemy cannot handle the attack and turned to a few extremists. The extremists, some of whom are called terrorists, are good at plotting conspiracies. Through a series of conspiracies such as crashing aircraft into skyscrapers and bombing subway stations, they successfully created massive fear among people.
What's more mind-boggling is that if you think about the cause and the consequences, heros and villains seem to be all mixed up. It becomes harder to distingush the right and the wrong, the good and the evil. And that's where people need to think harder, even though the process takes time, and courage, because safety is at stake.
The newly-inaugurated US president addressed to his people "the time has come to 'set aside childish things'." And one perticular example of childish things is to have "a simplistic tendency to see the world through ideological and partisan spectacles", and to divide "the world too often into good and evil". The courage to face threast squarely and to reaffirm the guiding values -- "honesty and hard work, courage and fair play, tolerance and curiosity, loyalty and patriosm"--provides a solid foundation to seek mutual interests and mutual respect with other nations and peoples.
When I was visiting a few friends at Stanford early this month, I saw a group of students demonstrating against Israeli war on Gaza. Some of them holding paper boards saying "US and Israel are real terrorists". The current crisis in the Gaza is just another drop of blood in the pot of simmering hatred. By the time I got back to TO, Israel offered truce. But the long-term peace, however, doesn't not seem anywhere near horizon. What seems to the western world as Palestinian missing opportunity to make peace is not anywhere near an opportunity at all, because peace is not charity, and shall be earned with digity, not defeat.
We as Chinese have learned that lesson long time ago. And in 2008, a string of events in China stirred many young minds again: the snow storm, the tibetan riot, the olympic torch relay, the Sichuan earth quake, and then fortunately Olympics, and then unfortunately the milk scandal. Being able to read reports in both English and Chinese doesn't seem to be a pleasant gift. I was astonished by how the east and the west portray each other, each claiming itself to be right, and the other wrong.
As China grows stonger and stronger, the power balance is tilting towards us, sometimes what is needed is to think once again about how we used to feel when we are less powerful. Knowing where we stand on crucial issues like territorial integrity isn't enough, isn't going to solve issues like tibet and taiwan without creating any unnecessary lingering resentment, because neither side is evil, and neither side is absolutely wrong, and because the difference between open-minded patriosm and narrow-minded nationalism is sometimes just a subtle line. The complex nature of these issues defies glib judgement and requires more than mere ranting of what should be done. Sometimes the end doesn't fully justify means, because means is as important as the end, because peace, is not charity.
The rat year, filled crises and feasts, distress and joy, is gone. The Ox year is coming, along with hope and prosperity.
Wish every friend a good year. 12/27/2008 Nothing can stop a nation when its time has come.
取自南方周末 http://www.infzm.com/content/21771。记海军远征,护航于索马里一事。 12/25/2008 节日快乐最近打电话回家,和爷爷聊到他最近刚刚参加的延安保育院的同学会。他说最小的也有81岁了。天!想象下五十年后,小学同学会,中学同学会,大学同学会。各位保重,好好活着,等着到时候收同学会请帖!!!
祝新年快乐! 9/1/2008 Barack ObamaAn extraordinary person with an exceptional character and a team of unusually talented people. If the America doesn't send this guy into the white house, it is doomed.
...
...
...
8/17/2008 crazy thoughtApparently, everyone talks about the Olympics in China, whether they like it or not. It is broadcasted 24/7 by at least 10 channels on TV; it is on front page of every newspaper; and it is fueled by the frenetic commercials of both domestic and foreign corporations. Everywhere I went, in Pudong airport, on the train back to Nanjing, and in resturants in Nanjing, I heard people talking cheerfully about how many golden medals China get today, as if they were the ones who actually on the sports field. It seems to me that this massive happiness was partly genuine delight and partly just a sense of pride, a little undue but acceptable, especially when I become part of it.
When I was watching the replay of the opening ceremony by CCTV, a crazy thought hit me. In the parade of nations, when a country's athletes passed the centrol stage, the head of that country would stand up and wave at his/her country's athletes. Many people dislike this show of politics at a sport event, and I am one of them. On the one hand, we are cheering for people like Micheal Phelps and Usain Bolts who push the physical limit of human as a whole. On the other hand, we are divided into people from different nations who compete with each other, and feel a sense of pride only when our own country's athletes get medals.
Just imagine, if you were some intelligent creature from another planet, watching this Olympics on earth at a distance. Do you think this species have a future?
Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.
- Charles Mackay 8/2/2008 14号回宁,20号抵京敝人将于北京时间14号下午三点到达浦东机场后,乘机场大巴回宁。在南京的兄弟姐妹们可有空一聚?
然后于19或20日北上赴京看奥运,可有弟兄有空铺借宿两宿?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这么快就两年了,
我回来啦!!!!!!!! 6/29/2008 So, I watched the movie Sex and The CityI've heard of the TV series for a long time, but never watched any episode. Early this month, the movie came out. And I happen to work with several high-power career-driven ladies, who all get excited about its release. And they are also eager to organize the group to see the movie. So, I watched the movie Sex and The City. Though I cannot say I enjoy the show, the movie does provide me with a totally different perspective on dating, marriage and of course love and family, from women’s point of view. Well, maybe not women’s point of view, but a woman’s point of view. During the dinner after the movie, when we talked about which one of the four girls we like the most, all of us unanimously voted for the woman who get pregnant in the movie, (who I unfortunately cannot remember her name.) which is not surprising, because after all we as hard-working scientiests (:-)) shared a lot of common values. But difference still exists. From the movie, it seems, at least to me, that women are more gregarious than men, which is more or less true. In the movie, the woman living in LA (cannot remember her name either) has a rare character. She seems to have an ego that surpasses most of the men, and is excluded by the German postdoc (F) in our group from her definition of “good” girls. Though I tend to restrain myself from labeling people as good or bad (and I do dislike her), that woman does create a case for guys to ponder what is a woman, (even though almost certainly without an answer) and how the egos of two people can clash. (If you change this female character into a male one, a somewhat familiar picture, though unpleasant, arises.) So, it seems to me that understanding does require a lot less ego and a lot more compassion. In a larger sense, an ego from the pride that seems totally legitimate and necessary in other occasions will weaken the ability to understand, and create clashes that might be otherwise avoidable; an ego from patriotism. When I read the posts from mitbbs.com, which claims to be the most popular website for oversea Chinese students, I am disappointed at people who posted how they “defend” China by arguing about other country’s misdeeds and by justifying heated action. One case in particular is about Taiwan. If you have a chance to get in touch with people from Taiwan, they seem to be more eager than you about arguing the Taiwan issue, which really surprises me. But if you put yourself into their shoes, and start think as if you lived in the island, you will begin to see the reasons. For example, if your hometown, with all your families, parents and brothers and sisters, are aimed by missiles, how do you feel? And say if you are banned from joining the community activities because your big brother says no in the community committee, what would you do? What would a person with dignity and pride do? I guess that’s why the chairman of KMT visits mainland last month, they said a decrease in the number of missiles aimed at Taiwan and a more open international stage are the two things they want most from CCP. The simple truth is that no ordinary people wants war, but things that ordinary people legitimately desire may differ and may eventually cause war. Whenever I see this argument from one side, everything seems to be altogether fitting and proper and I feel content. But whenever I tried to see it from the other side, it starts to create worry, disappointment, sometimes fear and anger. I put it now under the categoery of the symptom associated with supression of ego. .... .... There are no whole truths; all truths are half-truths. It is trying to treat them as whole truths that plays the devil. --Alfred North Whitehead 正邪本不分,一旦过于执着,就坠入了魔道。
PS. I think hard to have a point to conclude with, but no point seem to come naturally, so I left it as this post without a point. PS. Why do I need a point anyway? 6/8/2008 Surprise
Every now and then, life brings you a surprise, and two weeks ago, I got one, a very big big one. During my call back home last week, one of my little cousins secretly told me that my parents are arranging my marriage with the daughter of an old good family friend. It sounded so ridiculous to me that my immediate response was that my little cousin was joking. But she repeatedly warned me that I have to deal with it, better now than later, and she sounds very serious, not like joking at all. So after a while, I realize it might be true. Well, there are certain things we have to deal with in life, and unfortunately, the level of complexity goes up along the years. OK..., anyway, so, I have to deal with it. Saying no isn't hard; but saying no in a way without hurting, without damaging family friendship, and at the same time successfully persuading parents not to worry and not to interfere, is hard. It took me a while to think about what to say. And I talked online with the girl, and everything gets set. Then I called home last week. My mom didn't even mention this issue, which is not surprise to me. My dad, at the very end of the call, eventually asked. (or maybe because of the pressure from grandpa?) It seemed to be the strangest conversation I ever had with him, but I think I did say: let me deal with it, don't worry. But I knew they will keep worrying. Well, luckily, my little cousins will keep them occupied, at least for another two years, until she enters college. As an endnote, since there is no relationship to start with, luckily on one gets hurt. But from the perspectives of parents, they won't stop worrying until you get married. (Maybe not true, because then they will start worrying about something else, like baby and stuff... Anyway, you cannot change your parents.) I guess the only way to relieve them, though may be temporarily, is to keep them updated about your progress, not only professional, but also personal. Good luck to all my friends who are still looking for your Mr. Right or Ms. Right!
5/31/2008 新闻媒体展江:从总理流泪看新闻报道
"然而,如果说中央政府将“以人为本”落实在对灾民和灾区的体察、悲悯和救助的话,我们也不无遗憾地看到,受传统的思维方式影响,一些媒体在新闻报道中总是出现“各级领导高度重视”、“灾区群众情绪稳定”之类的语句,好像非如此不能显示制度的优越性,不能表现官员的亲民和对灾民的体恤。 温总理的身体语言和这次的媒体报道表明,上述媒体处理方式应该改变了,它们不但是不必要的,而且可能是有害的。首先,在民主和法制日益推进的今天,“观其行”已经成为人民考察政府官员的惟一尺度。其次,在这么大的灾难面前,铁人也要动容,上苍也会落泪,何况生离死别之百姓乎?灾民的恐惧、悲怆、哀痛属于人类最值得珍视的情感。第三,新闻媒体的第一大功能是监测环境,尤其是难测之风云,如果片面捕捉灾区人民“像过年一样的心情”,而舍弃更多反映灾情严重的画面,虽然媒体的镜头上一片祥和,但是全国人民何以全面认识灾情呢?"
----以前听到的总是新闻人抱怨没有新闻自由,报道受无形限制。反过来看看,什么样的体制就培养出什么样的人。文中说的受“传统的思维方式影响”已经是很给那些新闻人面子了。
“后来我们又想到了媒体。ZF无能为力管不了那么多,媒体能不能帮助呼吁一下社会各届的爱心人士或企业帮帮忙,让这些群众能在华西医院附近有个落脚的地方呢?有志愿者提到前些日子还有酒店跟ZF申请为救灾出力的。于是分别和一家四川的电视台、一家成都的电视台和一份成都本地的报纸都打了电话。在礼貌地听完我们的要求之后,接线员们都异口同声地说会把我们的事情反映给台里,然后再跟我们联系。可是后来全都没了下文。
一天下来,窝了一肚子的火气。回家打开电视,看见媒体又在报道某位领导又去“亲切看望”哪里的灾区群众了,某个大明星在那里在那里晃了一圈假模假样地作志愿者了,不由得更加火大:各个部门职责不清,相互推诿,难道这就是我们ZF的“坚强领导”下的行政系统?整天就知道跟着领导、明星的屁股后面传,用大篇幅报道他们说的那些地球人都知道的废话,对真正受灾群众的困难视而不见,难道这就是我们“众志成城”的媒体?”
----这是一篇被推上sohu新闻首页的博文,作者是专程回国做志愿者的留学生,在文末写下这样的话“中国媒体的先天不足让关注每一个人的人文主义和独立自主的批判精神成为看来很近,其实却还遥远的目标。”
----当我们前些阵子还在为西方媒体对西藏报道愤愤不平的时候,可曾想过中国的媒体又有多少“受传统思维方式的影响”而产生的偏见呢?
Nobody outside of a baby carriage or a judge's chamber believes in an unprejudiced point of view. - Lillian Hellman 5/16/2008 More than just courageThere is something more than just what the word "courage" can describe.
4/13/2008 无间道DLLM 要是他只是个宣扬compassion的僧人,事情就简单的多。或者,要是他只是个流亡政府的头头,事情也简单的多。但两者合二为一,麻烦就开始了。在世界的一边是近乎于神,在世界的另一边是众魔的头。和我谈起这事儿的西方人,多数支持他的compassion belief,同情ZD。但要说是由于赞同他的宗教信仰进而同情ZD,又有些牵强。 这几周来读新闻实在不是一桩轻松的事儿。看西方媒体的报道,看着看着就觉着闹心,就要浏览会儿新浪作为调剂。在这种事情上做到客观真不是件轻松的事。由这些事件引发出来的一系列讨论,很有看头。撇开那些必须坚持各自原有立场的国家级别的媒体报道不说,倒是一些自由评论人的观点值得借鉴。以下就是一则: “说起來,ZX問題真是一團迷霧,只要你朝它多走一步,你就會發現原來所相信的任何一種簡單立場都能碰上理據十足的反駁。不只現在的西方媒體造假與中國傳媒監控各惹嫌疑,歷史上的詭局謎團更是令人眼花撩亂。如果你認為「自古以來」,XZ就是中國的一部分;你將會發現要花很多時間去解釋古代宗主國對藩屬的關係為什麼等同於現代民族國家和它的轄下省份(越南反而確曾是中華王朝的一省)。反過來說,如果你相信在「中國入侵」之前,西藏是片連丁點暴力都不可能發生的和平淨土;那麼你又該如何理解14 任達賴喇嘛裏頭只有3 位順利活到成年的事實呢?假如你覺得文革對XZ的破壞是不可饒恕的,你或許應該知道當年打砸佛寺佛像的主力之一竟然是藏人。假如你認為中央對XZ的宗教自由已經足夠寬容,甚至准許流亡在外的眾多上師返鄉建寺(最有名的當屬頂果欽哲法王);你可能也曉得現在的XZ小學生是連隨身護符也不准帶的。 關於XZ的歷史,北京和DLLM各有一套說法。前者強調老XZ是塊大部分人充當農奴的黑暗土地,是共產黨一手把它帶進了光明的現代社會。後者則將XZ描繪為一個牧歌般的和平桃源,沒有爭戰只有靈性,是無神論的共產黨摧毁了這一切。 平心而論,兩者都各有偏頗,不足為信。XZ確曾是個農奴社會,1951 年前,光是三大領主經營的莊園竟然就佔了全藏可耕地的62%,其中又有37%為寺院所有。大部分平民都要在耕作之餘替領主服終身勞役。不過這些農奴的實况遠非中文裏的「奴」字所能概括,雖然身分是「奴」,但他們的物質生活卻不一定很差,所以在「劃成分」時才會出現了「富裕農奴」這麼古怪的類別。西藏確實也是個佛國,出家人所佔的人口比例舉世罕見。只不過和任何俗世社會一樣,以前的西藏也少不了各種勾心鬥角、貪污暴政甚至高層僧侶間的政治暗殺,與完美的世外桃源相去甚遠(詳見王力雄《天葬》、Melvyn Goldstein 的經典巨著《A History ofModern Ti-be-t 1913-1951》(中譯《喇嘛王國的覆滅》) 及《The Snow Lion and the Dragon: China,Tibet and the DLLM》)。” 再回来说DLLM, 他的middle way approach(自治但不独立)很可能让他两面都不是人。一方面想要得到中方的承认,另一方面又从CIA拿钱维持流亡政府;一方面公开支持奥运,另一方面又自称管不住手下四处暴力。 年纪大了,出来混的,总要还的。 |
|
|